Sick of waiting weeks for a dental appointment—only to feel rushed or ignored? We put you first with same-day appointments, treatment started today, and VIP-level service.
Patients of Dr. Carrie Pumphrey quickly discover that great dentistry can be both high-tech and deeply personal. With her as your dentist, you can expect same-day treatment, gentle care, and a truly stress-free experience from start to finish. Dr. Pumphrey is known for her calm, reassuring presence and her commitment to making visits efficient, comfortable, and completely transparent. Whether you’re here for a routine cleaning or a full smile transformation, she ensures every detail—technology, timing, and treatment—is centered around you. The result: exceptional care that fits your life, restores your confidence, and helps you love your smile again.
Dr. Pumphrey founded Blue River Dental in 2001 with one clear goal: to bring compassionate, efficient dentistry to the Shelbyville community she loves. Originally from Greensburg, Indiana, she earned her BS in Nutrition Science from Purdue University and completed her Doctor of Dental Surgery at Indiana University. She’s an active member of the American Dental Association, the Indiana Dental Association, and the American Academy of Oral Systemic Health, and regularly participates in professional study clubs to stay ahead of the latest advancements in care.
Outside the office, Dr. Pumphrey is dedicated to giving back through local organizations such as Girls Inc., SCUFFY, and the Major Hospital Foundation. She and her husband, George, are proud parents of two boys, Luca and Alek, and enjoy spending their free time outdoors and exploring new places together.
Patients love Dr. Betsy Crandall for her warm personality, gentle touch, and commitment to making every dental visit comfortable, positive, and judgment-free. With her as your dentist, you can expect a calm environment, clear communication, and care that’s personalized to your needs—not rushed or one-size-fits-all. Dr. Crandall focuses on building trust and confidence at every stage, helping patients feel truly seen, heard, and supported. Her goal is simple: to make dental care easier, more empowering, and even enjoyable for every patient she serves.
A native of Greenwood, Indiana, Dr. Crandall earned both her BS in Biology and Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) from Indiana University, and has proudly cared for the Shelbyville community since 2007. She’s an active member of the American Dental Association, Indiana Dental Association, and the American Academy of Oral Systemic Health which are dedicated to advancing clinical excellence and collaboration. Passionate about giving back, she supports organizations like Girls Inc., SCUFFY, and the Clarity Pregnancy Center.
Outside the office, Dr. Crandall and her husband, Ward, enjoy weekends on the lake, hiking, and spending time with their two children, Ollie and Ruby, along with friends and family.
We invest in leading-edge tools like CEREC, CBCT 3D diagnostic imaging, and 3D scanning so your diagnosis is faster, more accurate, and more comfortable. From same-day crowns to digital treatment planning, our tech enhances every step of your visit while helping us deliver exceptional outcomes with fewer appointments and less wait time.
f you need dental work, we do it today. No more multiple visits or dragging out treatment over weeks.
From the moment you walk through our doors, you’ll be greeted warmly by name and treated with genuine care and respect. We listen to your concerns without judgment and make sure you feel understood and valued.
Our modern, comfortable office uses the latest technology to ensure your visits are quick, effective, and stress-free.
